Challenging Court Decisions in Criminal Cases

In accordance with the Criminal Procedure Code of the Republic of Moldova, any participant in a criminal proceeding may challenge a court decision.

1) Ordinary remedies

According to Article 6, point 7) of the Criminal Procedure Code of the Republic of Moldova (CPC), ordinary remedy – a means provided by law for challenging non-final court decisions (appeal) or, as the case may be, which are not irrevocable (recursul);

  • 1.1) Appeal procedure (Article 400-4191)

    According to Article 6, point 17) of the CPC, appellate court – court that examines appeals against court decisions that have not entered into force (appellate chambers);
    • Sentences may be appealed for a new trial in fact and law of the case, with the exception of sentences pronounced by courts regarding crimes for which the law provides exclusively for non-custodial punishment.
    • The decisions given in the first instance may be appealed only together with the sentence, except in cases where, according to the law, they may be appealed separately.
    • Persons who may file an appeal (Article 401):
      • 1) the prosecutor, regarding the criminal and civil aspects;
      • 2) the defendant, regarding the criminal and civil aspects;
      • 3) the injured party, as regards the criminal aspect;
      • 4) the civil party and the civilly liable party, as regards the civil side;
      • 5) the witness, expert, interpreter, translator and defense attorney, with regard to the legal expenses due to them;
      • 6) any person whose legitimate interests have been prejudiced by a measure or act of the court.
    • The appeal period is 15 days from the date of the full sentence, unless otherwise provided by law. (Article 402).
    • Declararea apelului (Articolul 405).
    • According to Article 415 of the CPC, the decision of the appeal court:
      (1) The appellate court, judging the case in order of appeal, adopts one of the following decisions:
      • 1) rejects the appeal, maintaining the contested decision, if: a) the appeal was filed after the deadline, except for the cases provided for in art. 402; b) the appeal is inadmissible; c) the appeal is unfounded;
      • 2) admits the appeal, quashing the sentence in part or in full, including ex officio, based on art. 409 paragraph (2), and pronounces a new decision, according to the established procedure, for the first instance.
      • 3) admits the appeal, quashes the sentence of the first instance and orders a retrial by the court whose decision was annulled only in the case where the defendant was not summoned, his right to an interpreter was not ensured, his right to defense was violated or the provisions of art. 30, 33-35 were violated. The referral of the case for retrial may be ordered only once.
      (2) The sentence may be quashed only with regard to certain facts or persons or only with regard to the criminal or civil aspects, if this does not prevent the fair resolution of the case.
      (21) When adjudicating an appeal filed against a judgment of acquittal, the appellate court is not entitled to issue a conviction without hearing the accused - if present - as well as any prosecution witnesses requested by the parties. Prosecution witnesses shall be heard again if their statements constitute incriminating testimony capable of serving as a substantial basis for the defendant's conviction.
      (3) The decision of the appellate court is liable to be enforced from the moment of its adoption.
      (4) The decision to order a retrial of the case by the court whose decision was annulled is irrevocable.
  • 1.2) Ordinary recourse procedure (appeal in cassation)

    According to Article 6, paragraph (18) of the CPC, "recourse court" means a court that hears a recourse remedy filed against judicial decisions rendered in accordance with this Code;
    • Decision stage: The procedure concerns decisions that have already been rendered or examined by an appeal court (i.e. decisions that have become final).
    • Limits of review: The review is strictly limited to the legality of the judicial act. The recourse court does not reexamine the factual circumstances of the case, does not re-evaluate the evidence, and does not admit new evidence.
    • Objective: Identifying serious violations of substantive or procedural law, which occurred during the resolution of the case by the lower courts.
    There are two types of procedures that refer to ordinary recourse.
    • 1.2.1) Recourse against decisions of the courts of appeal (Article 420-436)
      Decisions subject to recourse (appeal in cassation) (Article 420).
      Persons entitled to file a recourse (Article 421): The prosecutor and the persons indicated in Article 401 may file a recourse.
      The time limit for filing a recourse is two months from the date of communication of the full decision (Article 422).
      Legal Grounds for a recourse (Article 427).
      Filing the application of recourse (appeal in cassation) (Article 429).
      Content of the application of recourse (Article 430).
      Admissibility of the application of recourse (Article 432).
      Decision of the recourse court (Article 435).
    • 1.2.2) Recourse against court decisions for which the right of appeal is not provided (Article 437-451)
      Decisions subject to recourse (appeal in cassation) (Article 437).
      Persons entitled to file a recourse (Article 438): A recourse against decisions for which the law does not provide for the remedy of an ordinary appeal (*apel*) may be filed by the persons mentioned in Article 401.
      The time limit for filing a recourse (application) against decisions for which the law does not provide for the remedy of an ordinary appeal (*apel*) is 15 days from the date the decision is pronounced (Article 439).
      Legal Grounds for a recourse (Article 444).
      Decision of the recourse court (Article 449).

2) Extraordinary remedy

According to Article 6, point 8) of the CPC, extraordinary remedy - a means provided by law for challenging irrevocable court decisions (review);

There are two types of requests within the exceptional appeal procedure.

  • 2.1) Review of criminal proceedings (Article 458-462)

    Grounds for review of criminal proceedings
    (1) Final court decisions may be subject to review, both in criminal and civil matters, at the request of the persons referred to in art. 460.
    (2) If the court decision refers to several persons or several crimes, the review may be requested for any of the acts or perpetrators.
    (3) Review may be requested in cases where:
    • 1) it has been established, by an irrevocable criminal sentence, that a crime was committed during the criminal investigation or in connection with the trial of the case which creates suspicions regarding the correctness of the solution in the contested decision;
    • 2) new or recently discovered circumstances have been established that the court was not aware of when issuing the decision and which, independently or together with the previously established circumstances, would prove that the convicted person is innocent or has committed a less serious or more serious crime than the one for which he was convicted or would prove that the acquitted person or the person in respect of whom the termination of the criminal proceedings was ordered is guilty;
    • 3) two or more irrevocable court decisions cannot be reconciled;
    • 4) The Constitutional Court recognized the legal provision applied in the respective case as unconstitutional;
    • 5) The European Court of Human Rights informed the Government of the Republic of Moldova about the filing of an application from which it is deduced the existence of a fundamental defect in the previous procedure, which raises substantial doubts regarding the correctness of the solution in the contested judgment;
    • 6) The European Court of Human Rights has found, by a judgment, or the Government of the Republic of Moldova has acknowledged, by a declaration, a violation of fundamental rights or freedoms, which may be remedied, in whole or in part, by quashing the contested judgment.
    (4) The death of the convicted person does not prevent the review of the criminal trial.
    (5) A request for review submitted repeatedly by the same person on the basis of the same reason is inadmissible.
  • 2.2) Resumption of the examination of the criminal case in the event of a trial in the absence of the convicted person (Article 4655-4658)

    Request for resumption of the examination of the criminal case
    (1) The person tried and convicted in absentia may file a request for resumption of the examination of the criminal case within 30 days from the date on which the court's decision was notified to him, against signature.
    (2) The examination of the criminal case may not be resumed if:
    • a) the convicted person was informed about the criminal trial and was unjustifiably absent from the trial of the case;
    • b) the convicted person had a chosen defense attorney who participated in the trial of the case in the first instance;
    • c) the convicted person, having been informed of the conviction, did not appeal or withdrew his appeal;
    • d) the convicted person requested to be tried in absentia.
    (3) If the extradition of a person tried and convicted in his absence is requested, the request for resumption of the examination of the criminal case shall be submitted within 30 days from the surrender of the convicted person to the authorities of the Republic of Moldova and the communication of the conviction decision.
    (4) The request for resumption of the examination of the criminal case shall be submitted in person or through a defense attorney to the court that last ruled on the merits of the case.
Alexhost - Webhosting support of the e-Legal.md Diginet.md - Ecommerce Solutions and Internet Marketing OpenCode.md - Open Source products and Digital Public Goods e-Cont.md - Issuance and circulation of e-invoices for payment for business in Moldova (B2B)